Doctor of Philosophy, Dissertation







In the 1920s, Dr. George L. Paik published his Yale dissertation, The History of the Protestant Mission in Korea 1832-1910,1 which has provided important historical resources for the period up to 1910. We examine the history of the Korean Christianity 1910-1960, focusing on conflicting Presbyterianism from historical, philosophical and theological perspectives. In this period, Korea experienced serious national and ecclesiastical controversies, and the character and direction of the Korean Christianity were molded.

A crucial question raised in the study of the contemporary Korean Christianity is why 'fundamentalistic' beliefs have come to predominate, especially in the Presbyterian circle. It is known that Korean Presbyterians in general are conservative, some of them are very conservative, and some others are extremely conservative. They are conservative to Reformed faith and tradition.

While the great majority of Presbyterian churches in most parts of the world has been gradually accommodated to modern developments and no longer hold the convictions of earlier decades, the great majority of Korean Presbyterians can still be characterized as 'orthodox' or stern Calvinists. This work presents cultural and historical reasons for the loss of authority and credibility of those who, in the Korean context, championed modern developments and for the continuing domination in Presbyterianism by the orthodox/conservative wing.

Cultural superiority of the Western perspectives has led some historians to see the history of the Korean church principally as a 'history of mission.' Under the influence of this view, for example, the miraculous church growth in Korea has been attributed to the Nevius Mission Method, which emphasized the Bible, and the strong conservative tendency is interpreted as the fruit of the missionaries who planted and molded the faith of the church during its early period. In a similar tone, other historians have simplified the history of the Korean church to that of theological thought: liberalism and conservatism.

The nationalistic approach is an alternative accentuating the role of the Koreans. The Minjung approach, similarly, weights the peoples' role in church history. Both approaches emphasize the particularity of Korean Christianity but fail to examine the universality of the church in its catholic and confessional nature and tend to be tied to a subjective and chauvinistic interpretation of history. All of these approaches, eventually, arrived at partial or superficial answers to the questions raised in the Korean church.

The Church of Jesus Christ exists in this world in a particular context that must be examined for its historical, cultural, national, institutional, political, regional, and sometimes psychological setting. The church exists in the world but is not of the world. The confessional and spiritual reality of the church transcends the boundaries of particularity. It is a universal and confessional community based upon faith in God the Father, the Son, the Holy Spirit, and Scripture and, accordingly, needs theological and biblical consideration.

To provide a balanced interpretation and clarification of the principles, power, and operating spirit flowing behind the history, I attempted an integrated approach; esteemed the particularity and universality of the church; and focused on the historical, philosophical, and theological aspects. I endeavored to see how the Church and Christians responded to what God wanted according to the principal teachings of Scripture: what the human being is to believe concerning God and what duty God requires of the human being.

I would like to express my sincere appreciation to the faculty members who have shaped my knowledge, academic insight, and critical thinking. Grateful acknowledgment is due to the Reformed Theological Seminary, Yale University, and Emory University, which have offered scholarships and stipends during my academic years. Library staffs of many institutions have answered my queries and made available important resources. My father and mother, my wife, Paul Pyunghwa, G-Heh Esther, and Hankook Moses, deserve special appreciation.

For the book titles quoted in Korean and other oriental languages, I have used the English equivalents. The bibliography includes the titles in their original languages.


Doug Choi

Korea Theological Seminary, Kosin University

Chonan, Korea


<저작권자 ⓒ 리포르만다, 무단 전재-재배포-출처 밝히지 않는 인용 금지>

▶ 아래의 SNS 아이콘을 누르시면 많은 사람들이 읽을 수 있습니다.

  1. 교파들 사이에 신앙고백적 차이가 없는가?

    교파들 사이에 신앙고백적 차이가 없는가? 원제: 화이부동(和而不同)은 가능한가?       한국교회의 신학적 정체성이 모호해지고 있는 증상은 여러 면에서 나타난다. 강단에서 외치는 설교에 응집력과 일관성 있는 교리가 없다. 확실성을 가진 진리체계를 제...
    Date2020.06.13 Reply0 Views780 file
    Read More
  2. Intellectual tyrant

    Intellectual tyrant The growing and deepening polarization of our society is making people an intellectual tyrant. The atmosphere of judging and condemning the other person with a confrontational view of politics has passed over the normali...
    Date2020.05.13 Reply0 Views13759 file
    Read More
  3. 지적 폭군

    Burchard of WormsㅡBishop of the Imperial City of Worms (재위 1000-1025) 지적 폭군 최덕성 해석학 강의록 1: 머리말      "자기가 본문을 해석하는 게 아니라 본문이 자기를 해석하게 하라"(어거스틴)   우리 사회의 증대되고 심화되는 양극화는 사람들...
    Date2020.05.12 Reply0 Views583 file
    Read More
  4. 쌍두마차시대

    쌍두마차시대 최덕성 교수의 『쌍두마차시대』(2012)를 읽고/ 정태홍 박사 교황과 황제 그리고 중세 망딸리떼 무릇 책이라는 것은 제목을 보면 ‘그 책이 무엇을 말하는가?’하는 답이 나와야 한다. 요즘에 나오는 책들을 보면 너무 감성적인 제목이 많다. 제목...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views852 file
    Read More
  5. 종교개혁전야

    종교개혁전야 최덕성 교수의 <종교개혁전야>(2003)을 읽으면서/ 최재호 최덕성 박사와 만남   1. 내가 본 최덕성 박사   최덕성 박사를 처음 만난 것은 2000년대 초반 고려신학대학원에서였다. 높은 콧날과 금테 안경 너머로 보이는 강렬한 눈빛은 그가 매우 ...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views564 file
    Read More

    THE ROOTS OF THE PRESBYTERIAN CONFLICTS IN KOREA, 1910-1950 Doctor of Philosophy, Dissertation DOUG CHOI EMORY UNIVERSITY, 1992     PREFACE      In the 1920s, Dr. George L. Paik published his Yale dissertation, The History of the Protestant...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views3169 file
    Read More

    THE CONLICTS IN THE VIEWS OF THE BIBLE, PCK Master of Sacred Theology, Thesis DOUG CHOI YALE UNIVERISTY, 1985 Introduction   The Bible is the foundation of theology, the primary source for Christian knowledge, and a basis of the Church chur...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views13025 file
    Read More

    KOREAN CHRISTIANITY   Book Review   KOREAN CHRISTIANITY: THE PREDOMINANCE OF REFORMED ORTHODOXY by Douglass Choi, Ph.D.   I have long felt that there was a need for such a book Korean Christianity: The Predominance of Reformed Orthodoxy(Ana...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views19324 file
    Read More
  9. 단순한 삶이 아름답다

    단순한 삶이 아름답다 (가본) 예문:  단순한 것이 아름답고 편리하다        1. 최첨단 기계   나는 대학교에서 가르치는 일을 하기 전에 여러 해 목회자로 봉사했다. 목회를 하는 동안 교회당을 건축한 적이 있다. 약 2만 평의 부지에 총 면적 약 500평의 ㄱ...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views405 file
    Read More
  10. 자아통제력이 강해야 성공한다

    자아통제력이 강해야 성공한다 (가본) 예문: 어린이는 완전한 사람이다 1. 덜 자란 어른 텔레비전 프로그램 “경찰청 사람들”은 “덜 자란 어른”이라는 제목으로 실제 사건 하나를 극화하여 방영했다. 고등학교를 졸업하고 독일에서 6년간 대학과 대학원을 다닌...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views424 file
    Read More
  11. 자존감이 높여야 두뇌가 좋아진다

    자존감이 높여야 두뇌가 좋아진다(가본) 예문: 어린이-우리의 희망, 가능성 덩어리    하나   어린이는 작은 우주이다. 상상력의 천재이며, 가능성 덩어리이다. 그 가슴에는 원자탄의 정력과 고양이의 호기심과 시인의 감정을 가지고 있다. 예술가의 혼, 독재...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views280 file
    Read More
  12. 아버지의 그림자도 밟지 말라

    아버지의 그림자도 밟지 말라 (가본) 머리말: 대박이 쏟아지는 자녀교육        아주 탁월한 자녀교육 방법, 대박이 쏟아지게 하는 자녀교육 책은 없을까? 자기 자식을 잘 키우고 싶어 하지 않는 부모는 없다. 자식을 잘 키우고싶다고 하여 저절로 되는 것이 ...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views369 file
    Read More
  13. WCC 바로 알라

    WCC 바로 알라 최덕성 교수의 <WCC 바로 알라: 네 이웃에 대하여 거짓증거 하지 말라>(2013)을 읽고/ 변정희 기자 1. 유익한 신학논쟁   어거스틴은 당대의 교회의 필요를 채우는 글을 쓰는 과정에서 기독교사상사의 주류를 형성하는 여러 가지 신학적인 답을...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views540 file
    Read More
  14. WCC 무엇이 문제인가?

    WCC 무엇이 문제인가? 최덕성 저 (서울: 총회출판국, 2010) 세계교회협의회(WCC) 제10차 총회(부산, 벡스코)를 앞두고, 최덕성은 아래의 표지 그림의 <WCC 아이덴티티>(서울: 본문과현장사이, 2010)를 출간했다.  WCC 신학의 핵심 사상을 10가지로 정리한다. ...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views1274 file
    Read More
  15. 신학충돌 II: 한국교회와 세계교회협의회

    신학충돌 II:  한국교회와 세계교회협의회 최덕성 교수의 『신학충돌 II:  한국교회와 세계교회협의회』(2013)를 읽고/ 권세일 박사 한국기독교의 이종서식(異種棲息)   최덕성 교수의 『신학충돌 II: 한국교회와 세계교회협의회』(2013)는 세계교회협의회(Wo...
    Date2020.03.25 Reply0 Views485 file
    Read More
Board Pagination Prev 1 2 3 4 Next
/ 4